Alex Denis

We are so honored to tell these victims’ stories. In this case, Karie’s father shares his heart with us. Karie was a beautiful soul and is still missed by many. Link to video is in comments. Please share.

Karie Newberry was 17 years old. A young mother raising a baby boy named DJ.

One night, Karie went out… and never came home.

The next morning, her car was found sitting in the driveway. The keys were still inside. Her baby was back in the house.

But Karie was gone.

What followed was a search that would lead investigators into the woods, and to a discovery that would change the entire direction of the case.

Forty years ago, Bonnie Booker vanished. A mother of four, Bonnie was in the middle of leaving her husband when she disappeared. He told police she simply walked away after an argument at a gas station in Bellevue, Tennessee. Was it a kidnapping? A murder? Or had Bonnie chosen to disappear?