True Crime Witch

A woman who has been missing since she was 13 years old has just been found alive and well in Arizona.

She wasn’t kidnapped,or taken against her will. She chose to run away. This is the story of Christina Marie Plante.

In May 1994, 13 year old Christina Plant headed up to her stable in Star Valley, Arizona. She told her aunt and uncle she wouldn’t be long, but she never came back.

A massive search was launched for the missing teen, but very few clues were found.

Investigators uncovered that Christina had spoken about running away before, but her friend’s didn’t think she was serious.

At the time of her disappearance, she was living with her aunt and uncle, and was very unhappy with the situation. Investigators classified her disappearance as an abduction, but the case quickly grew cold.

For 32 years the community believed the case would never be solved, but the Gila County Sheriff’s Office was determined.

Finally, in April 2026, they made a shocking breakthrough. Details are scarce, but we do know they ‘utilised new technologies’ to find Christina as an adult.

When officers tracked her down, she confessed and made another shocking revelation. She had run away.

Some articles have said Christina, who now lives under a new name, met with her mother the day she disappeared.

It is believed the pair took a flight out of Arizona and Christina has been living elsewhere ever since.

Christina has asked that her new identity be kept secret and details of her new life have been omitted from reports.

She told investigators that her disappearance was ‘her old life’ and she wants to get on with her life, and her family in peace.

𝐇𝐨𝐰 𝐝𝐢𝐝 𝐚 𝐬𝐭𝐮𝐝𝐞𝐧𝐭 𝐯𝐚𝐧𝐢𝐬𝐡 𝐝𝐮𝐫𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝟗𝟓𝟎𝐌 𝐰𝐚𝐥𝐤 𝐭𝐨 𝐡𝐞𝐫 𝐝𝐨𝐫𝐦❓

19-year-old Suzanne ‘Suzy’ Lyall was like any other student at SUNY Albany. She had exams, reports and deadlines to contend with, all whilst trying to juggle a social life and a job. One cold evening, Suzy got off the bus and was headed to her dorm, but she never arrived. Why did Suzy disappear, and who used her bank card?

Suzy Lyall was born in Saratoga Springs, NY, to Doug and Mary Lyall. Growing up, Suzy was obsessed with computers, and when the family got their first PC, she couldn’t wait to take it apart to see how it worked. Naturally, after high school, Suzy opted to study computer science at SUNY Albany.

This placement was perfect; Suzy’s boyfriend, Richard Condon, lived nearby, and he was also interested in computers. The pair had met at school, with Richard being a few years her senior. To help cover her rent, Suzy got a job at a computer store in the Crossgates Mall in Albany.

On March 1st 1998, Suzy called her mother, Mary, like she did most nights. During the call, Suzy wished her mother a happy birthday, and the pair chatted about Suzy’s upcoming midterm exam. Mary said that Suzy was laser-focused on studying, but seemed stressed and tired.

The following day, Suzy went to her job at the mall. Her boss stated that Suzy was stressed about the exam she had taken that morning, but she seemed otherwise happy and cheerful. Sometime after 9 PM, Suzy closed down the shop and headed to the bus stop.

There are conflicting reports; however, we know that Suzy disembarked sometime around 9:30 PM. The bus dropped her right outside of her dorm, and it would have taken her a matter of minutes to walk there. After this, Suzy completely dropped off the map.

It wasn’t until the next morning that people realised the student was missing. According to Mary, she received a call from Richard, who said, “Did you know that Suzy didn’t come back to her room last night?” The Lyalls panicked and reported their daughter missing to the campus police.

The campus police did not take the report seriously, assuring her parents that she had probably stayed out at a party. But the Lyalls knew their daughter. She didn’t smoke or drink and was more interested in her part-time job and her exams.

A search of Suzy’s dorm room showed no clues; her clothes were piled neatly, her hairdryer had been left on the bed, and her glasses were on the bedside. It didn’t appear that Suzy had made it back to her dorm, so what happened in that 950-metre walk?

Bank records showed that at 4 PM on March 2nd, someone had withdrawn $20 from Suzy’s account at an ATM 2 miles from campus. CCTV showed someone wearing a baseball cap using the ATM at the time the transaction was made. Whoever used the card put in the pin correctly on the first try.

It has not been definitively proved who used Suzy’s card, and it remains a bizarre detail. Suzy’s parents turned their suspicions toward Richard Condon. Mary Lyall told CBS that Suzy had tried to break up with Richard several times, but he was able to reel her back in every time.

Mary Lyall also mentioned to the police that 2 weeks before Suzy disappeared, she asked her mother to stop off at Richard’s house to give him a letter. In Mary’s mind, this was a break-up letter, although Suzy never mentioned anything to her. Her parents believe that their relationship was unhealthy, and Suzy wanted out.

Another bizarre clue comes from Suzy’s boss at the mall. He told police that Suzy had spoken of possibly being stalked. Although she never expanded on this comment, and did not appear afraid of anyone.

Richard Condon, Suzy’s boyfriend, gave police a tight alibi, but Suzy’s parents think he is involved. Richard never went to Suzy’s dorm after she disappeared, nor did he join in search efforts. He refused to cooperate with the police and refused a polygraph test. Police have found no evidence of Richard’s involvement, and he remains innocent in the eyes of the law.

Suzy’s parents joined the ‘Cold Case Cards’ that are given out to prisoners. These playing cards contain photos and information about cold case missing person cases or murders. Unfortunately, Doug Lyall passed away in 2015, never knowing what happened to his daughters.

Mary & Doug Lyall became staunch activists following Suzy’s disappearance and are pushing for ‘Suzanne’s Law’. A law that requires police to accept missing persons reports for those aged 18 to 21. It is still being pushed and debated in Congress, but this bill would bridge the gap from children to young adults.

Despite mass media and police attention, no sign of Suzanne Lyall has ever been found. 13 years before Suzanne disappeared, another SUNY Albany student, Karen Wilson, vanished from campus. Unfortunately, there has been no progress in Karen’s case either.

Suzanne Gloria Lyall is described as a white female with brown hair, blue eyes, 5’3” and 175 lbs. She has a light birthmark on her left calf, a surgical scar on her left foot, moles on her cheeks and pierced ears. Anyone with information is urged to contact the New York State Police at 518-630-1708, quoting case no 98-164/SJS 301 3335.